AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for Devonna

by Persephone

person Person with Taste
schedule November 17, 2003 at 12:00 AM
Ok, time to review some things about bad fic: 1) Crossovers are almost NEVER a good idea. Especially not in incompatable fandoms. I know HP and LotR are both fantasy, but that is the only similarity between them.

2) Mary Sues are the bane of the fan fiction world. Do not write them, EVER.

I couldn\'t even read this entire story, it is such complete BAD FIC!!!

This has been a flame.
person Person with Taste
schedule November 17, 2003 at 12:00 AM
Ok, time to review some things about bad fic: 1) Crossovers are almost NEVER a good idea. Especially not in incompatable fandoms. I know HP and LotR are both fantasy, but that is the only similarity between them.

2) Mary Sues are the bane of the fan fiction world. Do not write them, EVER.

I couldn\'t even read this entire story, it is such complete BAD FIC!!!

This has been a flame.
person Person with Taste
schedule November 17, 2003 at 12:00 AM
Ok, time to review some things about bad fic: 1) Crossovers are almost NEVER a good idea. Especially not in incompatable fandoms. I know HP and LotR are both fantasy, but that is the only similarity between them.

2) Mary Sues are the bane of the fan fiction world. Do not write them, EVER.

I couldn\'t even read this entire story, it is such complete BAD FIC!!!

This has been a flame.
person Devonna
schedule June 5, 2003 at 12:00 AM
great fic. glad u finally posted it. i don\'t eat shit, or get raped.
But otherwise , it was grand
person Jenna
schedule June 1, 2003 at 12:00 AM
hello, I am the famous Jenna in my husband\'s story \"Devonna\". I must admit that most of the content in this story is true....except that the sorting hat isn\'t actually lonely! lol. My best friend and husband, Katherine the author of this story is very talented and I am very proud of her for releasing our naughty secrets online
Love always, Jenna