schedule
March 25, 2004 at 12:00 AM
aaaaaaaaawwwwwwwww. Oh my god, i can\'t believe how sad you made it... i can just SO picture it... i can hear the songs in my head, it\'s fantastic! Well, i won\'t fake that i like the end. On the one hand, i can understand it, it would be difficult for a teacher and a student. But what about after Hogwarts? It would be possible, wouldn\'t it? Well, i would suggest a sequel, but a complete new story is probably better. ;-) I just don\'t like that the end is so... final. There is no hint of hope.
Despite that, your story is/was wonderful, (just like the \'Phantom of the Opera\', i may add. ;-)) and i highly enjoyed being drawn into the world of the phantom again.
Despite that, your story is/was wonderful, (just like the \'Phantom of the Opera\', i may add. ;-)) and i highly enjoyed being drawn into the world of the phantom again.
schedule
March 25, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Bloody hell that was good! Long, but well worth the length. This story had me sitting at the edge of my seat for the duration of it, with the suspicions and accusations made on couples. Very well written! I\'m glad the SnapexHarryML group held the Top 10 Snarry fic I m I might never have known such a marvelous work of fiction existed.
schedule
March 25, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Fantastic job with this story. I have been reading it since the very first chapter, and this is in fact, the first fic I ever read on AFF.Net. I just wanted to say you took three of my favorite things and rolled them into one (Phantom, Harry Potter, and Snarry) I have to say that you did very well with characterization and everything. Fantastic!
schedule
March 25, 2004 at 12:00 AM
NooooooooooooooooooooooooooooOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *Cries out loudly!!!!* noooo How could it end like that!!!!!!!!! It was heart breaking!! I\'m crying damn you! I never really cry after reading ficlets! But but this!!!!! Oh you evil evil person! After that wonderful awesome story the ending oh no!! I\'m going to kill myself now! Bye cruel world! .................... ......... *Calms down* Well actually not killing myself that would be qiute drastical and sorry for me cursing you but I was really pissed with the ending. It was sooo Perfect! Can you write a sequel? Pleaseeee I\'d give anything for a sequel! Well after all this ranting I\'ll tell you I loved this ficcy you\'re writing style is brilliant you transformed my favourite musical into my favourite fanfic story ;)
Necromant
Necromant
schedule
March 25, 2004 at 12:00 AM
W I h I have just read the last chapter and the only thing I can say is...SEQUEL! I\'m a \"happy endings\" kind of person and this was not a happy ending. Though it truly wasn\'t a sad ending either, just not a happy one. After having read this story, I\'m going to go back and listen to my \"Phantom\" disks again and I went an watched Moulin R too too, which I never thought I\'d do.
Although, as much I love Severus, I\'m afraid no-one but Michael Crawford is *the* Phantom for me. Still, excellent casting there and I like the way Harry didn\'t get a huge role. I\'ve read a lot of stories where they want to make him the star and he can\'t do *everything* perfectly. I enjoyed the story immensely and congratulations on an excellent piece of writing that, *because* it didn\'t have a happy ending, was realistic and at the same time hopeful.
Q the Immortal
Although, as much I love Severus, I\'m afraid no-one but Michael Crawford is *the* Phantom for me. Still, excellent casting there and I like the way Harry didn\'t get a huge role. I\'ve read a lot of stories where they want to make him the star and he can\'t do *everything* perfectly. I enjoyed the story immensely and congratulations on an excellent piece of writing that, *because* it didn\'t have a happy ending, was realistic and at the same time hopeful.
Q the Immortal
schedule
March 25, 2004 at 12:00 AM
thats what i call a bittersweet ending! Really good from the start till the end. I can see the start of affection from harry and sev and it makes it more realistic than otheother fics ive read. You add more couples in it and mix it with the main plot and It\'s great touch because I could swear I\'ve seen the signs yet it took me a chapter or two until i know for sure. I like the dynamic between the couples, less explosive true, but really realistic, with jelousy, suspicious, mistunderstanding.
I hope you have a sequel?
it took JayKay to finish hers Too woo to peacefuly in 3 stories *grins*
I \'m hoping for a happy ending for Sev x Harry and always will
thank you for writing a great story that make me amuse, laugh and sad at the same time
I hope you have a sequel?
it took JayKay to finish hers Too woo to peacefuly in 3 stories *grins*
I \'m hoping for a happy ending for Sev x Harry and always will
thank you for writing a great story that make me amuse, laugh and sad at the same time
schedule
March 25, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Aaaaaw!!! That hurt! You do *not* want to know how badly I\'m crying right now! Would it be very silly of me if I asked for a sequel?? I just can\'t stand te the them both so miserable... and even more important than that: there are so many loose ends! What will happen after the holidays? And what about Harry, will he keep the promise he\'s made? And Severus? Why did he whisper that thing in Harry\'s ears, far from his eyes, when he\'s just sung that hearing isn\'t to be trusted, that it\'s deceiving??
Arrgh! <-- sound of Iani going mental (not that she ever was quite sane, mind you)
Anyway... I loved it. Absolutely loved it. I oved the amazing plot, how realistic it was, how wonderfully you portrayed the characters, and the beautiful way in which you used the songs.
Tip for everyone who reads this and wants to re-read the chapter: read it while listening to TPotO soundtrack. This amazing lady, here *points to the author* has written it so that you find the dialogues and narration pieces during the bits of the songs which have no lyrics. If not, she skips a few lyrics, and once you\'re finished reading what the characters are saying, your CD will be singing exactly the next line you find in the chapter. Trust me it\'s true, you only have to skip songs every now and again.
So.... complimeagaiagain, and do think about a sequel! And now, everyone: three hurrays for our great author!
Arrgh! <-- sound of Iani going mental (not that she ever was quite sane, mind you)
Anyway... I loved it. Absolutely loved it. I oved the amazing plot, how realistic it was, how wonderfully you portrayed the characters, and the beautiful way in which you used the songs.
Tip for everyone who reads this and wants to re-read the chapter: read it while listening to TPotO soundtrack. This amazing lady, here *points to the author* has written it so that you find the dialogues and narration pieces during the bits of the songs which have no lyrics. If not, she skips a few lyrics, and once you\'re finished reading what the characters are saying, your CD will be singing exactly the next line you find in the chapter. Trust me it\'s true, you only have to skip songs every now and again.
So.... complimeagaiagain, and do think about a sequel! And now, everyone: three hurrays for our great author!
schedule
March 25, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Arrgh! <-- sound of Iani going mental (not that she ever was quite sane, mind you)
Anyway... I loved it. Absolutely loved I o I oved the amazing plot, how realistic it was, how wonderfully you portrayed the characters, and the beautiful way in which you used the songs.
Tip for everyone who reads this and wants to re-read the chapter: read it while listening to TPotO soundtrack. This amazing lady, here *points to the author* has written it so that you find the dialogues and narration pieces during the bits of the songs which have no lyrics. If not, she skips a few lyrics, and once you\'re finished reading what the characters are saying, your CD will be singing exactly the next line you find in the chapter. Trust me it\'s true, you only have to skip songs every now and again.
So.... compliments again, and do think about a sequel! And now, everyone: three hurrays for our great author!
Anyway... I loved it. Absolutely loved I o I oved the amazing plot, how realistic it was, how wonderfully you portrayed the characters, and the beautiful way in which you used the songs.
Tip for everyone who reads this and wants to re-read the chapter: read it while listening to TPotO soundtrack. This amazing lady, here *points to the author* has written it so that you find the dialogues and narration pieces during the bits of the songs which have no lyrics. If not, she skips a few lyrics, and once you\'re finished reading what the characters are saying, your CD will be singing exactly the next line you find in the chapter. Trust me it\'s true, you only have to skip songs every now and again.
So.... compliments again, and do think about a sequel! And now, everyone: three hurrays for our great author!
schedule
March 25, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Aaaaaw!!! That hurt! You do *not* want to know how badly I\'m crying right now! Would it be very silly of me if I asked for a sequel?? I just can\'t stand to see them both so miserable... and even more important than that: there are so many loose ends! What will happen after the holidays? And what about Harry, will he keep the promise he\'s made? And Severus? Why did he whisper that thing in Harry\'s ears, far from his eyes, when he\'s just sung that hearing isn\'t to be trusted, that it\'s deceiving??
Arrgh! (sound of Iani going mental (not that she ever was quite sane, mind you))
Anyway... I loved it. Absolutely loved it. I oved the amazing plot, how realistic it was, how wonderfully you portrayed the characters, and the beautiful way in which you used the songs.
Tip for everyone who reads this and wants to re-read the chapter: read it while listening to TPotO soundtrack.s ams amazing lady, here *points to the author* has written it so that you find the dialogues and narration pieces during the bits of the songs which have no lyrics. If not, she skips a few lyrics, and once you\'re finished reading what the characters are saying, your CD will be singing exactly the next line you find in the chapter. Trust me it\'s true, you only have to skip songs every now and again.
So.... compliments again, and do think about a sequel! And now, everyone: three hurrays for our great author!
Arrgh! (sound of Iani going mental (not that she ever was quite sane, mind you))
Anyway... I loved it. Absolutely loved it. I oved the amazing plot, how realistic it was, how wonderfully you portrayed the characters, and the beautiful way in which you used the songs.
Tip for everyone who reads this and wants to re-read the chapter: read it while listening to TPotO soundtrack.s ams amazing lady, here *points to the author* has written it so that you find the dialogues and narration pieces during the bits of the songs which have no lyrics. If not, she skips a few lyrics, and once you\'re finished reading what the characters are saying, your CD will be singing exactly the next line you find in the chapter. Trust me it\'s true, you only have to skip songs every now and again.
So.... compliments again, and do think about a sequel! And now, everyone: three hurrays for our great author!
schedule
March 24, 2004 at 12:00 AM
This is fantastic! I always say, \'A great story moves you, through tears, joy, sadness, and anger.\' And you have done just that~! Oh, and If you stop now, I\'ll find a way to murder you ;p