AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for Havoc of the Opera

by Roman

person Aany
schedule March 28, 2004 at 12:00 AM
That was one very spectacular piece! I cried at the end, (its my favourite too, do you think he\'d sing it for me?) screamed out loud in abject horror when Hermione and Severus kissed (nice touch, by the way) and laughed out loud when Ron finally came to his senses. I loved the way you made Severus to be such an evil nice guy (you know what I mean!) He was so sarcastic and realisitc and irritating, but he was so nice to Harry... oh! :(
Harry on the other hand was as irritating as possible- but i don\'t like OotP Harry, so don\'t take it personally!
Loved the whole story, the idea and the fact that you actually updated!!! Yea!!!

Love Aany x x x
person Isabel
schedule March 28, 2004 at 12:00 AM
WHAT!? THATS IT!? YOUR GOING TO JUST STOP THERE!? WHY!? Please please please I\'m begging you 't d't do this too me!!! To everyone!!! Will Snape leave? Well yes I suppose he will...but that last comment!!! About what he felt for Harry!? Come on!!! At least do an epilogue...a sequel...ANYTHING!!! JUST DON\'T FINISH IT THERE!!! *dies*
person Inzilbeth
schedule March 28, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Please don\'t let this be the end.
person Rayba
schedule March 28, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Ouch. It hurts. It hurts NICELY. Oh, my god, how I love you... One of the most beautiful and touching ends I ever readed. I was hoping it would be good, but in fact it was almost too much. I just fell in love again with Severus. I hope you will write a sl, Pl, PLEASE. The story was great, the plot amusing and moving (the end almost made me cry...), at this moment I just want to go to my pencils and start drawing Severus in PotO costume... Yay!
Good job. Really. You are one of these authors that keeps me reading fanfic.
person Souzou Kyuuketsuki
schedule March 28, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Hullo, you bastard ! ^^
lol excuse me...
Ahem. Well, I really loved it all, even if I kept hoping that all would be well in the end... But you didn\'t mean it that way apparently, even if it ends well in a sense.
Well, my heart hurts and I feel like crying (that I didn\'t fell in a while)... Well written, really good plot... I\'ve been angry with Hermione but eventually...
She\'s great with Draco...
And Harrd Sed Sev are... really... I don\'t know. It\'s unfair. But original. For once, their relationship is a bit realistic.
Will there be a sequel?

Bye, and congratulations...
person Anata
schedule March 27, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Oh My God! You did it! I\'m bawling!!!! And my nose is all stufromfrom crying! OH MY GOD. You can\'t mean to end it there!! (although I do enjoy a bit of angst now and then) That\'s UNBELIEVABLY sad!!! I can\'t comprehend it! There are so many different emotional levels that it hurts my heart to read it! This is so beautiful and I\'m still crying and I\'m just in love with this piece. I can\'t even form proper enceences, that\ow mow much this affected me! This is so amazing and touching and powerful. The emotion in this shatters my heart. *wipes eyes* I have a lump in my throat from crying.
It can\'t end like that...It can\'t.
*sniffl*sniffl* Waaaaaaaaaaaaaa~ ;-;
Anata, President of the Roman Fanclub ^.~
person Melissa
schedule March 27, 2004 at 12:00 AM
I loved your story!! I\'ve been following for a while and Phantom of the Opera is one of my favorite musicals. I really liked how you worked the lyrics into the story. I find it impressive when an author can come up with a story around lyrics like this and you made it work. Call me a geek, but I listened to the soundtrack as I read your story. Congratulations on a job well done!!
person MiaSnape
schedule March 27, 2004 at 12:00 AM
There is this feeling of heaviness and fullness all over me, and I don\'t know whether or not it\'s a final kind of feeling.
This was an equisite story, simply equisite. I especially loved the part just before Snape left during \'Moulin Rouge\' and, of course, the very end. Very bittersweet and beautiful. The writing really echoes the storyline and the characters feelings, so bravissimo.
As to whether I would love you to do an epilogue or sequel...
\"I don\'t think I know, anymore.\"
person Fox
schedule March 27, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Roman, really, what can I say? The perfect blend of romance and angst. Just beautiful, really. The ending had me sighing wistfully. I loved it! ^^ (Am I the only one who really loves being slightly saddened at the end of a story?) I wouldnt mind a sequal (a lot of the other reviewers have been asking for one), but I think that the ending suits the fic and its mood perfectly.

Kitsune
person yiota
schedule March 26, 2004 at 12:00 AM
NOOOO!!!!!!!!!!

You can\'t just leave it like that. I\'ve been waiting a month for this. Please update soon!!!!!!