rate_review Reviews

Wow! Thanks for sharing this story - truly superb plot and writing, and an excellent ending too!

Hello there,
Just wanted to tell you I have, as incredible as it seems, got over the ending now (well, almost anyway^_^). I read my review again just now and it actually made me smile... I\'m also ready to confess that the ending was one of the major reasons why I like this fic so much. And you know, after ...hmm...perhaps more than six months, this is still the best fic I have ever read. Honestly.
I can see why you\'re hesitant to write a sequel. I agree with you. But, you know, if you ever happen to write a sequel that is just as good as this one, feel free to let me now.
*Hugs*
Ps. I have also almost forgiven Dumbledore *pets*

This was the sweetest, cutest, most fantastic and saddest snarry I\'ve ever read!!!! Please, please, PLEASE write a squel. I adore this pairing and Phantom of the Opera. Really great work!!!

Oh My God!!

I think I might cry, I LOVE this. I just spent over nine hours reading this fic.

Good god this is an awesome story, have you written any before or after this?

I love it, love it, love it.

It fits so well. And I knew even though I was hoping for a happy ending, I knew what would happen.

*tears leak out of the dam*

This is soooo fits in with the characters. It didn\'t seem ooc at all to me.

If this idea was in the books, this is how it would turn out, well if it wasn\'t a \'kids\' book, at least.

I love this, love it, love it, love.

Have I told you that I love this?

This is just so awesome, there were parts that were really screwed up in the formatting that it was hard to understand what was going on, but the rest of the fic is just so awesome.

Keep up the most awesome writing skills I have seen so far.

Now let\'s see what else you have written.

Keep up the excellent work, Coolsa.

I just read this and I loved it, totally. (May 2005) I\'ve read the epilogue and now understand, even more, what the impact of reviewing is to an author. I always try to review, every chapter or set I read.
I can sincerely say, that you, Roman, are incredible. How fic writers come up with some of these stories and make them work, to almost canon likeness, I will never figure out. The tangents these stories strike out on are pure genius.

My congratulations on a very fine piece of work.

Roman, I swear, I cannot put into words how incredibly amazing this fic was. It was absolutley beautiful, and even though it was very sad, I thought that it was perfect. Not saying that i would have minded a happy ending, lol, but i truly did LOVE this fic. It kept me up late for nights in a row either reading it or just thinking about it. It is truly the best fic i have read so far, and now my all time favorite. Thank you so much for writing this

Ah, this was actually my second read-through, and considering the recent scare that AFF might be gone for good, I thought I wouldn\'t take your lovely piece of art for granted anymore and review this time. The first time I read \"Havoc\", I had never seen/ heard \"Phantom of the Opera\", but I still found the plot to be wonderfully enchanting. This time, I was equipped with my soundtrack. The emotional quality of your writing paired with the songs made the experience even more pleasurable. I actually was on the verge of tears at one point. My only critiques about this story are the misspellings and typos; usually I won\'t read a story with these things in them, but your idea was so good that I stuck it out and thoroughly enjoyed myself. Thank you!

Ok so like i check my other e-mail something i have not done in forever. and i see you sent me and e-mail.. and i am like \"ROMAN!!!!\" so i skip everything i have to read what you have to write.. then i start reading everything on the page... aww.. you are so sweet.. really. it\'s my my fault you wrote sucha brilliant story that i could say nothing bad about it at all. i miss reading it... i have to save the whole thing to my computer all over again too... hmm.. tho i still wish they would have ended up together in the end... that would have been nice. i hope you get this. e-mail me sometime my new e-mail addy is with this review. later roman..

Miki

the Gryffindors, who