rate_review Reviews

This is such an incredible story. I must've read this at least 20 times now, it's so captivating. A sequel would be a dream come true, or maybe even this story but put in Snape's POV. Great work!

such a wonderful story. i wish it had ended on a happier note but i know it's perfect just the way it is.

*CRY* so good! T____T poor harry and severus.... <3

How could you???!?!?!?!?! Fits the original ending soundtrack of Phantom tho. (Learn to be Lonely). Damn, its heart breaking.

I loved PotO, I listened to the soundtrack as I read, too bad I didn't have Moulin Rouge too.

Great story, I can totally imagine Snape as Phantom.

Good job.

absoluntly brilliant!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

It's sad, but it's very sweet. I found this when it was just in it's beggining stages and I can't tell you how eager I was to read it. I love the Phantom of the opera and to stuble upon this was...The apsolute best find I've ever had the pleasure of reading. I have to say you are a genious of the rarest kind, it trully takes a creative mind to take two such wonderful stories and transform them into something even better. When I first saw it I thought 'Great another sappy fluffy Harry and Snape fic' but lords above did you give me a good wake up call! After reading the first three chapters I checked every day to see if you updated and wanted to rip my hair out when you hadn't. I can't tell you how many times I pulled an all nighter reading this. (but trust me some of my grades are enough of the proof)

You trully are a writter among writters and I hope to read and enjoy more by you. Sad or not I think this was a true master piece and I apploud you. Bravo!

I.A. Blackwater

P.S.
I think you try to do an original piece, with your mind I think it would be fantastic!

This shall forever be one of my top two ABSOLUTE FAVORITE stories of all time. I don't say fan fiction, because in my mind, they are their own works. Of course you borrowed characters, but you gave credit were it was due, and thus the piece remains yours. I've read this over and over...and still I love it. My heart aichs for the lovers. I so long to know if Harry kept his word...but then, I suppose that would be a nother story entierly, wouldn't it? But oh, to see wether or not Severus comes back to find Harry in his bed would be the greatest thing for me. Did the relationship continue, despute what they said...or do things really return to how they once were? Does Sev go back to treating Harry like crap? My heart just cries out for the knowledge...my soul is going crazy..and my brain just won't let the questions go....
I hunger for more, though I fear that if I were to recieve that which I so desire, the rest of this epic would be lost on me. And so, I thank you for writing something that I do so cherish.


NEVER STOP

Ever Adoringly Yours,

AdenDiction
Addiction

I absolutly loved your fic, melancholy as the ending was I think it was fitting on the whole. I specifically liked Draco and Ron's interactions, thier dislike is evident and you didn't try to force a happy relationship between the two.
I have to admit I did not read the whole fic in one go, I started it a few months ago without having seen the movie. Now that I have seen it though I enjoyed it much more.
I think it was also the possible Hermione Snape pairing, not a big fan of that, that set my off the beginning, I like her much more with Draco, despit the het. ew. lol.
Well done, and a sequel would not be untoward if you ever have a craving to write one.

rocking ... or should i say operating lol fic

loved it!!

great! I am an avid fan of both PotO and HP so it's really nice to see them combined. Although, there are some lines in the PotO play that were wrongly typed. I guess you need not revise them anymore coz your already through with your story. But anyway, nice story all the same! btw, I'm a DHr and Erik/Christine shipper........ so........ you get it ;)