AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for What If

by BlackDawnRose

person CDGaymer
schedule November 7, 2015 at 12:00 AM
very good chapter, i hope harry will be ok.
i wont mind if its dray/nev/harry or nev/harry, eaither would work. Or u could start it as Nev/Harry and bring Dray into it later
person Anon
schedule November 7, 2015 at 12:00 AM
It's sick if ron gets to stay in school. He should go to prison
person zsfantasy
schedule November 6, 2015 at 12:00 AM
I love this story. It is very unique and keeps my interest. I love the quiet and shy Harry that you portray. I would like to see a Neville/Draco/Harry pairing. I think that it has been nicely set up. I also am hoping that Ron and the rest of the Gryffindors will be properly punished now that responsible adults are aware of the situation. Thank you for another great chapter.
schedule November 4, 2015 at 12:00 AM
hi
brilliant story so far
please keep updating
just a little note on this chapter when they are all sitting in the compartment you have put talking about their summers. but they had just come back from their Christmas holidays. just thought you would like to know and also in chapter two when Neville is asking harry "do you only draw animals or other things too?" and harry replies "I draw other things too" at the start of the class you started out calling the professor, professor sprout but after Harry's line about what he draws you changed it to Madame pomphrey, and then went back to calling her professor sprout. again thought you should know besides that
absolutely love this so far
please update soon cullengal101
person Jan
schedule October 22, 2015 at 12:00 AM
Poor Neville, of course he hadn't noticed Harry in that light before, what with being with Dean and all, then with having caught him cheating on him, and him being in pain of course he hadn't notice that he had been more then interested in Harry until now, lol(so cute) please update chapter 5 soon.
person Anon
schedule October 22, 2015 at 12:00 AM
lols. Neville is so 'gone'. Even with whatever issues Harry has, i think he is still a far better match for Nev than Dean was. I honestly can't see Harry ever condoning bullying... or cheating behavior.
I wonder how long it will be before Nev realizes he's head over heels again?
person Anon
schedule October 21, 2015 at 12:00 AM
I really am enjoying this

Sev
schedule October 12, 2015 at 12:00 AM

Please correct your disclaimer.


Your disclaimer doesn't have one of the two parts we need to see. You must use the actual name of the fandom. Just naming the owners/creators of the fandom, or saying that you don't own only the characters is not enough.


What happens if the disclaimer isn't fixed? We allow seven (7) days for the story to be corrected. After that, we hide it, and it will stay hidden until it's corrected or until it's been thirty (30) days since we hid it. At that point, we do delete the story. If we do hide your story, you can always access it through your Control Panel in your archive profile even while it's hidden. If we do hide your story, and you've fixed it, you can contact the ToS team with the name of your story, your username and the fandom where the story is located to have your story made visible again. You can contact us by email at TOS_team@adult-fanfiction.org. Just one thing: Re-uploads of hidden stories are deleted immediately with no additional warning given.


Here's a link to the Terms of Service:

http://www.adult-fanfiction.org/tos.php


This link is to the FAQ about disclaimers, with some examples:

http://www2.adult-fanfiction.org/forum/index.php?showtopic=3560


We also suggest taking a few minutes to read the Content Guidelines:

http://www.adult-fanfiction.org/guidelines.php


You can remove this review once your disclaimer is corrected.


Thank you,

Dafdes, AFF Archive Moderator

person elle
schedule October 11, 2015 at 12:00 AM
I really like this story. It's an intriguing AU. I hope you keep it up. The interaction between Draco and Neville is fun
person bill560682
schedule October 10, 2015 at 12:00 AM
as to the question someone else asked about harry being a wimp and scared is going back to his upbringing. he was raised by his mother who protected him from everyone and everything he never had to learn to stand up for himself.this harry was thrown into the big bad world after a whole life of being protected 24/7 by his mother and here he has no protector. this harry never had to turn to get bad grades no matter how smart you are to prevent beating. this harry never had to turn how to out smart dudley and his gang in games of harry hunting. cannon harry learned at a very early age no one is going to be there to protect you all the time but yourself.