AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for Guilty as Sin

by harriet

person Pookie_Ookie
schedule December 15, 2005 at 12:00 AM
I absolutly loved your story, from beginning to end! It was just amazing and well detailed. i can't wait for you to come out with a second story to this one, aand though Draco was a tad odd and rather annoying at some piont, he was still ... well Draco. Anyhoos, I loved it, still here and probably will come sniffing back for more! ^ - ^
person Hecate18
schedule December 15, 2005 at 12:00 AM
I loved it!!!
This was the fic that 'distracted' me from my coursework many many times; but I can't complain, I enjoyed every minute of reading it. ^_^
I was persuaded to like it, although I've never been too fond of Harry/Snape pairings... there's only a few fics that have the ability, and I'm thankful I stumbled upon this one!

~Hecate18~
person Philomel
schedule December 15, 2005 at 12:00 AM
*applauds* I loved this story! The ending ist TEH CUTENESS! The characters were well developed, and I liked the way Harry had to get used to this other side of him. The relationship between the three was a bit too brutal for my taste, though it suits the story fine.

(BTW, the ending -ei sounds like egg in German, so I, being a native German, had to concentrate hard not to read "Superei" as "Superegg" - This lead my flatmate to put a sign on her door saying "Don't you dare challenge the Superei!" because it has that ssecond meaning *g*)
person LazySnake
schedule December 15, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Actually I have read most of your stories. Mainly those with the word complete in the summary.
I am always waiting for that word to appear than I will clear up my whole day and snuggle down to enjoy your story. They are just so delicioius.
Sorry for being an ass and only writing one review for all the efford you have put in all your stories. I will try to review all the other stories after I have savored Guilty As Sin. Does this story have mpreg? I am a sucker for them especially if fluff is in the equation. Nevertheless all your stories are amazing.
^_^ Keep up the good work.
person acr
schedule December 14, 2005 at 12:00 AM
I was kinda dissappointed in the ending, to be honest. It was too easy. I also wanted to see Harry confront Ron and Remus.
person Crimson Rose-Angel
schedule December 14, 2005 at 12:00 AM
I LOVED IT! I think there should be a sequel or something.
person deb
schedule December 14, 2005 at 12:00 AM
trust me this has not been done before lol
person antipyro
schedule December 14, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Wow! Love the ending. It kinda leads into a new adventure for Paris and Aramis, maybe with the older trio saving them from something unknown about Elith-Feratu (Sorry if the spelling is wrong - I'm going from memory here).

Wadda' mean, you hate fluffy endings...... - this IS as fluffy as you get - NO ONE DIED! So it's a great ending!!!!

I don't really believe the "no ideas left" story either......Your stories are cherished for their ingenuity, detail and canon-likeness, never mind the angst, humour and tragedy that pervade through them. Life is full of it and you manage to pull out what can possibly happen and make it work. Pure genius!

Thank you sooooo much for another fine piece of work. Rest well, and don't stop writing.
person Donavon
schedule December 14, 2005 at 12:00 AM
I hate it when one of your stories comes to an end. Write more soon.

I loved it!!!! Draco was a whining prat but what else is new. I adored your Snape he could slap me
around anyday.

Best wishes HOW ABOUT A STORY FOR CHRISTMAS FOR YOUR READERS AND FANS. COME ON WE DESERVE IT
PLEASE.........
person tessa3
schedule December 14, 2005 at 12:00 AM
well that was a disturbing ending lol.. anyhoo.. OVERALL: I FUCKING LOVED IT!!!! YEs.. there were certain parts that i turly hated but then there were parts that had my eyes go like this O.O and then there were parts that mead me say DAMN and so on and so forth.. but i am sad to see it end but *shrugs* ah well.. que sera sera.. loved it