AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for Catalyst

by cruttan

person Michelle
schedule October 25, 2005 at 12:00 AM
WOO HOO! The Dread Pirate Malfoy! I love it. Keep the updates coming - this is SO much better reading than my homework....

Cheers,
Michelle
person Sygnus
schedule October 25, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Cat, Got a wonderful laugh about this chapter. Wonderful job as always.. I was nearly rooting for a harem girl and a sulton LOL!! As always can\'t wait for the next part of the story!..

Syg
person Petalsoft
schedule October 25, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Loved it! Draco as a pirate.... phew! Course I also liked the first costume he picked for Hermione. I think it was supposed to be the Princess Leah one when she\'s the slave of Jaba the Hutt??? (I think) that would have been fun too. And the drunk slip of the L word from Draco --- yes, that was nice! Bet that made Hermione all warm and fuzzy. Can\'t wait for more!
person mrs_accio_firebolt
schedule October 24, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Hi. I\'m new to your story, so I\'ll just leave a 10-chapters-worth review today, and ask you to include me on the update list.

I don\'t even know where to start. Maybe with a confession. Here it is: I don\'t usually read stories with thin-waisted, long-legged, perfect-breasted Hermiones, Ginnys, Pansys; nor broad-shouldered, full-lipped, incredibly sexy Malfoys, Harrys, Rons. It really takes me a long time to see past that and let a good story take a grip on me. I started reading your story because Lorett reccommended (sp?) it and I\'m certainly pleased that she did so.

Let me say that one of my favourite characters in the Harry Potter series is Harry Potter. I cherish friendship beyond anything else and I see Harry as the perfect portrait of friendship. And your Harry, so caring, and protective of Hermione has won my heart. But what I liked most about him was that he KNOWS. He knows Hermione and her virtues, her defects, her needs, her moods. He knows all of her. And I love that.

Another one of my favourite characters is Lucius. Mainly because of CoS. Jason Isaacs represented such a perfect Lucius Malfoy... But this Malfoy is just ADORABLE. His interactions with Narcissa are just price-less. I can so perfectly picture him as this sarcastic, funny, talented, meddlesome person. Bonding with his wife and child in such a way that only a loving husband/parent can. You\'ve made a wonderful job of destroying canon Lucius and giving us a delicious fanon version of him and his wife. Bravo! And I mean STANDING OVATION. I almost fell off my chair when he\'s terrorizing a house-elf in front of Hermione and he turns around to say \"He\'s new.\" OMG! Just soo Lucius but so new-Lucius at the same time. I think you\'re doing a great job with all your characters, but with Lucius it\'s simply perfect. Or the scene where Lucius and Narcissa are \"grinning like Cheshire cats\". Hilarious. \"Have I not taught you over the years to play nicely with the girls you like?\". People at my office actually stared at me. Soooo funny!

Besides your obvious ability at developing characters, I would also like to congratulate you on your ability of creating moods, of transmitting emotions. \"He patted her awkwardly, finally caving at the sight of the weeping female and pulling her to him, wondering at the bizarreness of the situation\". I could just see them. I could perfectly understand Draco\'s unease and reasons for moving. I loved that line. And taking advantage of that ability, I feel that you should have made the \"meet the parents\" scene last longer. I was already rubbing my hands together to witness (so to speak) a brilliant battle of the wits... and it was over too soon.

I\'d also like to tell you that you got me worried at one point when Harry admits to having told Draco that he should ask Hermione out. I thought it was going to get all messy, that she would cancel the date, that Draco would have to fight to get on her good side again... but you skillfuly (sp?) spared us from that sort of un-needed twist. I don\'t see Hermione as such a clingy, irrational person. So, thanks for that.

And since I\'ve come across Draco, I have to say I love your Draco. He\'s sexy, he\'s perfecto. I don\'t know if you like or even tolerate slash. If you do, I think you would enjoy a fanfic called \"Ab Epistulis\" by autumn-lecroix. Your Draco reminds me of that one. PLEASE do not misunderstand me. I just think they have the same over-all type. When the sexiness doesn\'t come only from being handsome, but from power, wit, culture. The story is also strongly based on some epistular conversations between the main characters... and I might add here that I enjoyed very much the funny letters, even if few of them, that went between Draco and Hermione.

As for the sexy love scenes, you\'re also doing a wonderful job. \"overcome by the sensation of being surrounded by the beautiful little witch he had come to adore\"................... It simply left me without words.

Please don\'t forget to include me in your mailing list, as I\'ll be eagerly looking forward to chapter 11.

Much love,
accio.
person Happilyjaded (not logged on)
schedule October 23, 2005 at 12:00 AM
I found this story via someone\'s favorites, and am thankful for it. This is great! I love Hermione\'s innocence and awkwardness, it\'s so very realisitic. Narcissa is a delight to read as well, and Draco, Merlin, he\'s delicious. This is a very cute and sexy story, with delightful moments of humor and drama mixed in. Bloody fantastic, I can\'t wait to read more. Thank you for sharing. ~ElizabethJade
person moon
schedule October 23, 2005 at 12:00 AM
OMG !! that was so hot ! Again, it\'s a great chapter ! and I can\'t wait for more ! I\'m so glad that you are nominated again for \'Catalyst\' at the Drangerous Liaisons Awards !

Wish you luck,

Moonie
xxx
person HiddenAllusion
schedule October 22, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Heehee... crookshanks makes a reappearance! Lovely last few chapters... I like the way you\'re developing this, and especially your characterisation of Narcissa. And, of course, Crookshanks! Thanks
person RahNee
schedule October 21, 2005 at 12:00 AM
Hey Cat! I am soooooo very sorry that I have not popped over here to review sooner! I actually started reading Catalyst a while ago, and got as far as the first date, and something, I\'m sure, came up in real life and sidetracked me... Lo and behold, I\'m suddenly 4 chapters behind! And, I had to go re-read so I could be up to speed... so I spent some time last night reading, way past my bedtime, I might add, and I am now going to review.

(Ahem.) I FREAKING LOVE YOUR STORY!!!

Your Draco makes me all weak in the knees. My tummy tingles. My heart goes pitter-pat. I need a cold shower. Get the picture?

In fact, I love the way you are writing ALL the characters. I had so much FUN reading this story. That\'s why I am now DYING for the next chapter! I must have more soon...I\'m needing more hot, sweet, snarky, sexy, to-die-for Draco, please! Heh heh. (Looks expectantly at computer. Realizes something...) And I need you to add me to your update list (see email above) so I can know the INSTANT you update.

You are a fantastic writer, and I\'m enjoying hanging out with you on the 3Keys group site!

Talk to you soon!!!
Ronnie

person liz
schedule October 21, 2005 at 12:00 AM
This is a really good ff... I hope that the next chapter will be out soon... it\'s great
person Sygnus
schedule October 21, 2005 at 12:00 AM
This story is so well Writen, you have stay true to the characters and have a totally belivable plot, I found myself pulled into the story. Have to say I can\'t wait to see more.. If I didn\'t know this was fan fiction.. I\'d swear your just JK under an assumed name.. Well Done!

Syg