rate_review Reviews

I read HBP and I was thinking the SAME things! I was reading and all of the sudden I had maybe 10 pages left...and I was thinking \"What the HELL?\" That sucked so horribly how it turned out, nobody seemed right and just...ugh! As amazing as JKR is, I think I prefer the fan fiction. By the way, I love your story...I\'ve never read anything that went so in-depth about Pansy...and I\'ve never reviewed before haha but your comment just was exactly what I was thinking. Here\'s to hoping Book 7 fixes it all.

I\'m not sure if this is really the end of Dumbledore. Voldemort didn\'t completely die off before. I just have a feeling that J.K. may have it that Snape used the potion the Draught of Death I think it\'s called, and that Snape and Dumbledore planned this \'fake\' murder. Afterall, that potion was one of the potions boiling in the pot during the first day of potions. When I think about the past books, J.K. likes to give little clues like this at the beginning of a book and you don\'t find out their significance until later.

I still have hope that Draco will switch sides in the end. He couldn\'t get himself to kill Dumbledore.

As far as Lavender\'s \"won won\" I think she was trying to speak a form a cutsie baby talk, like gushy couples sometimes do, by substituting the R for W\'s . Won Won = Ron Ron

I don\'t think Dumbledore was OOC. He\'s always been a bit wacky at times. Anyways, these are just my opinions.

BTW, that was a sweet last chappie with Pansy and Draco.

accually i just had thought. What if Rowling wrote this to make it confusing. she couls have done that easily. Though it does seem like it\'s a fanfiction in a way.

Not a bad story, keep it up

I must admit, I have not finished it yet, I\'m on page 457. It\'s almost like she was trying to placate us all, people want 1) Dumbledore to acknowledge that he was wrong to leave Harry at the Dursleys, 2) Harry as Quidditch Captain, with Ron and Ginny on the team, 3) Harry falling in love with Ginny, etc. This is not the woman who killed Sirius.

i know, i read it in 5 hours, its just like JK didn\'t write it! What the hell is up with dumbledore and Snape, what the hell is going on?!?!?!?

Now here are my thoughts to the things you put in your A/N

Dumbledore is soooooo OOC in the first chapters... he behaves like luna! Dumbledore does seem a little strange but then again he\'s always strange
when the hell did ron and lavender start dating?? I have no fucking clue and I didn\'t like it! I didn\'t like how he was going out with her!
lavender saying \"won-won\"??????? Fucking werid. That girl has issues
when did harry suddenly develop feelings for ginny? (i mean, it could happen, but plz plz a little more explaination!) I feel that there has always been something between Harry and Ginny since the first book and he found out he had she had a crush on him. And like Ginny explained in the book, Harry never really got to see the real Ginny until his fifth year when she got over her school girl crush for him. He finally got to see how she really was as a person and Harry had loads of time to think about that and seeing Ginny and Dean kissing, well that just clairified his feelings for her.
harry is just over sirius\' death!?!?!?!?! He wasn\'t really over his death, he sometimes couldn\'t even say his name when he was speaking about him.
Does Lupin seem a little OOC? Not really, Remus is going through a tramatic time in his life right now, I feel he can be however he wants
How about Luna? Luna was a little off in this book
the DADA teacher and the minister are a little.... wierd? Yes they were really werid, I would have rather seen Lupin comes back as DADA
Tonks and Lupin got together a little suddenly (agian, it could happen, but not that suddenly!) Tonks seems to have had feels for Lupin for a long time and by their discussion in the Hospital Wing, they had talked about her feelings for him before hand. How she liked him but he felt he was \"Too old, too poor and too dangerous\" for her. They must have talked about it when they left the Hospital wing and Tonks had convinced him just how much she loved him. I know Remus has probably always had a soft spot for her and loved her too but was too afraid to admit it.

Well those are only my thoughts.

It seemed a bit different, yes, but it\'s still JKR\'s writing!

Ron and Lavender got together because ron is trying to make hermione jealous and im only half way through reading it dumbledore will always be ooc because that\'s just him. i agree with you about the whole won-won. what the hell does it mean.i think harry has fancied Ginny for awhile but he just finally realised it. it is weird that he\'s over it and not shocked or whatever over it. accually lupin does seem a little ooc. not luna so much though. the minister creeps me out. and the new potions master creeps me out too. and i haven\'t gotten that far in Harry though to know about tonks and lupin soo...

I totally agree with you. I hated the fucking book. I loved the third one and fourth but that\'s about it. I don\'t really understand it. I mean I can\'t stand dumbledore or snape, and I love Harry/Ginny fics. So them dateing was great, but with the dumbledore thing and then Snape really being evil. Like come on. It was just complete bullshit. The way she has left it now is it\'s either going to be a happy ending with harry living in the seventh book or him and voldimort both dieing. That second one I think would be a bigger possibility.