AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for Should Have Been

by Rochelle

schedule April 3, 2009 at 12:00 AM
well...
this is really interesting. i'm enjoying it so far, but some parts are a little unclear to me. in chapter three (i think), there seemed to be a paragraph or two missing between sirius going into siri's painting room and remus explaining what happened between him and sirius's family. also, there are a lot of errors in this. spelling and such. i think it's the formatting, not you, but it's very distracting and i have to guess at words.
hmm... as much as i was enjoying the fluffiness, Dark Stories are some of my favorites, right up there with Grievously Angst-Ridden and Helplessly Romantic. i hope you keep writing, because i would love to read more. siri is sweet, though the whole vampire-thing is...weird. anyway...yeah. keep writing and posting, and i'll be back for more!~
person ananomuse
schedule January 25, 2005 at 12:00 AM
I hate to say this but there are alot of time where i have to guess what you are trying to type,its almost like you are making up words
person Padfoot the Marauder
schedule August 29, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Perhaps you're trying to compensate for the fact that the story is almost over, but posting the same chapter twice isn't exactly what I call a subtle space filler. ;) Quickly upload the real chapter eight and I'll forgive you for getting me all exited over nothing.

hugs,
Padfoot.
person Pinky
schedule August 23, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Love the story so much. I like how you put so much thought into the plot. Makes me look like a real slacker cause all I write is smut. Its also one of my favorite pairings in the whole wide world. If its not to much trouble could you e-mail me when you up date that would be great. Keep on writing, and if you geta chance please read my fics that are posted on the site. Thanks so much.Till I review agian.
Cheers, Pinky
person Padfoot
schedule August 20, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Oh! This is really good and really well-written. Although I hate the thought of Remus and Snape, I love Remus and Sirius, which outbalances it. ;) Please update soon!
person Cat
schedule August 15, 2004 at 12:00 AM
I loved this story and i love that name Sirius Cerberus Lupin. ^_^
I agree Snape was being quite unfair by cng Mng Moony a Whore but still thats Snape for you.

Remus/Sirius is my third fav pairing after Ron/Harry, Harry/Draco and Snape/Lucius, anyway it was great, the way you captured Remus' and Sirius' feelings in a realistic way rather than the NORMAL happly ever after ending was excellant.

*+*KittyQ*+*
person shamanogler
schedule July 31, 2004 at 12:00 AM
well i never read the old version so i dont know what i have missed,.....but i would just like to add my encouragement to carry on with this one. it is a lovely story so far and i really like siri\'s character. i can\'t wait to meet siri\'s much disaproved of friend either. i\'d also like to see siri and harry meet.

anyway, looking foreward to seeing how this one develops

shamanogler
person madisonfairie
schedule July 16, 2004 at 12:00 AM
This is so cute! I can\'t wait to read more. Personally I have always felt that there is no way that Harry is the only child of all four of the Mauraders.