AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for Smoke and Fire

by Skool

person Shampoo
schedule April 12, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Amazingly good story! I could go on and on about the fabulous sexual tension, writing and clever plot. Dying to read the next chapter and see what Hermione and Snape do next...they are so adorable together. Update again as soon as humanly possible, please! ^_^
person devsgma
schedule April 12, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Ah!! No, I got to the end of Chapter Three and there wasn\'t a Four. I\'m really enjoying your story. I really liked Severus being jealous of Mr. Rickman. Just a small critique - if you could put a line between your chapters it would read a lot easier. The character development is really good. I like your Snape and Hermione very much.
person deblovesdragon
schedule April 12, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Hey this is fun! I loved how she finally broke down and sent an owl. The Shakespeare was cute. You may want to have him be careful with his little games. They may cause him trouble later.
I love how you have these two socially inept people together.
Cheers.
person Victoria
schedule April 4, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Lookin good. I like a drunk Severus Snape who isnt violent. But surely he deserves at least a good wank with company!

Aw man. Passing out in a bed upstairs w/o even so much as a good grope in the morning. Poor dears.

My only complaint is your punctuation. Once you\'ve established a quotation, and put the question mark (?) or whatever INSIDE the quotes, theresno need for an additional comma. EX: [\"In thunder, lightning, or rain?\" he said, and smiled.] He doesnt SMILE a quote, and theres no comma after the quotes. {\"I am a sexy man,\" he said.} I placed a comma inside the quotes because theres no ? or !.Or you could {He smiled. He said, \"I am a sexy man.\"} Placing a comma inside the quotes at the beginning is a spanish thing to do. Here, place the comma after the non-quote to indicate that the quote is part of the sentence, and not a typo.

I like that Hermione shows her other sides in this. Usually she\'s too sex-kittenish, and not smart enough, or too brainiac, and not sexy enough. Come on- gimme another chapter. Surely she at least gets to SAMPLE the goods!
person XxphenixX
schedule April 4, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Very nice, my dear. I do love the challenge guidelines that make the characters all the more realistic in their imperfections, and I think you did a very good job of using them to your advantage, The intellectual in me applauds your Shakespeare, as well. The impatient smut-hunter in me glares at you for lack of said smut. I should probably stop detailing the responses of my various personalities, but they\'re all so different and all begging to review. The logical me, however, realizes I don\'t have the time at the moment (sorry!). Therefore, I thoroughly enjoyed it and can\'t wait to read more from you. Ciao!
person Niceven
schedule April 4, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Brad Pitt, Tom Cruise, and Antonio Banderas...do I smell Interview with the vampire? You have a humorous idea going on here. I like your little inserts of wit it keeps it interesting. I can\'t wait to see more.
~*Niceven*~