AFF Fiction Portal

rate_review Reviews

for A law to herself

by Shiv5468

person elisa
schedule April 22, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Blackmail, bribery, and corruption, now where have I heard that before? ;^) Nope can\'t say that I give a sod about Ron\'s answer but am growing increasingly curiousr Snr Snape\'s. Wonderful as always, Shiv.
person kuniklo
schedule April 22, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Thanks for the great fic, I have really enjoyed it thus far, read it twice even! The funny bits, and the rest. I am not quite sure how to describe it, but it seems like there is no extraneous text, or bits thrown in that don\'t have value. If you let this one fizzle out I will never forgive you! hen hen you had Harry do a clever, it made me think of how in the books he occaisionaly comes up with a really funny insult (like when he told dudley the toilet might be sick because it never had anything as nasty as his head in it). I can\'t even think of a HGSS fic where harry gets a funny insult in.. so like, you should do it!
person ElfWitch
schedule April 22, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Dumbeldor proposing.........Super! Hermone character is very alive. Good dialogs.Write MORE!!!!
person gthistle
schedule April 22, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Oh, excellent. Not only does Hermione remember to do research on a topic that can be researched, but what she finds makes sense in context (I mean stylistically and tonally). Plus, Severus gives backhanded assistance, and because it\'s directed at Hermione not Harry (as it was in Philosopher\'s Stone), the trio figure it out. Glorious. The most OOC part of the chapter, and not by much, is the Hogwarts library--though perhaps it has a back door through one of those portraits to Borges\' Library, which in the story\'s world wouldn\'t surprise me at all.
person elisa
schedule April 21, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Oh I loved Poppy, she\'s being helpful without being fussy and Severus is helpful without being noble. It\'s all so right. Excellent job!
person maggie
schedule April 21, 2004 at 12:00 AM
the first thing that came to mind when i noticed the new chapter was schawing, shortly followed by wahoo, and after reading the latest chapter all i can add is wow! I love your stories, they have a wonderful mix of humor and realisim. so all i can say is keep up the beyond exellent work!
maggie
person Anon
schedule April 21, 2004 at 12:00 AM
This story is great! Hooray for clever Hermione. I also very much enjoy Snape\'s stealth help :)
person Deb >^..^< .
schedule April 21, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Chapter 3... Very interesting!!! I do like Poppy\'s attitude towards all of this!!! I also can\'t say that I blame Albus for wanting to be a father, but maybe he should look for someone a bit older;-)

So severus is helping without helping, smart man!!! I can\'t wait to see what they find out about the potions!!!

Who was she going to marry indeed;-) I can\'t wait to see how she goes about figuring it out & then suggesting it to the man she chooses, should be quite interesting all the way around!!! Til chapter 4, Deb >^..^<
person deblovesdragon
schedule April 21, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Very clever Shiv. So, she just has to marry a pureblood (who will that be again?) in a muggle ceremony and then the laws of the Marriage Act will not apply to them.
Good one. No one\'s come up with that before. Very original.
I won\'t even ask you to update this soon, cause you\'re writing (what) 4 stories now. Whenever you update this, I will read it with fervor.
Cheers.
person WendyNat
schedule April 21, 2004 at 12:00 AM
Loving it more and more... I really like your Poppy in this fic, particularly this line: \"Not to mention that beard; have you noticed how much food gets trapped in there. Frankly, it